In Todd Walker’s defense, he plays for a team with six players in the top twenty-five in the AL in OPS. The only other Red Sox out of the top-25 is Johnny Damon. Of course Johnny Damon plays a nice center field, steals bases, and has an .860 OPS since the All-Star Break. To put it plainly, of the nine Red Sox regulars, only eight contribute. One kills them.
Hypothetically, what would the numbers for a bottom five defensive second baseman have to look like in order to consider him a contributor? This is pretty unscientific but I would say that he would absolutely have to be one of the eight to ten best offensive producers at his position. Call ten his breakeven point.
Well Todd Walker is one of the five worst defensive second basemen and he is certainly not one of the ten best offensive second baseman. He’s not even close.
He is seventeenth (for 2nd Basemen) in OPS right behind Orlando Hudson and just ahead of Luis Rivas.
In RC27 for 2nd Basemen, he is eighteenth – behind Hudson again and just ahead of Mark Ellis.
In EQA, he is again eighteenth this time ahead of Hudson and just behind Jerry Hairston Jr.
It gets worse. You want to see his numbers this summer, during the push for the playoffs (in BA / OBP / SLG form)?
July: .206 / .239 / .308
Aug: .133 / .184 / .178
He has been an abomination – just terrible. He is a bad fielder – a very bad fielder and for a month and a half now he has been an even worse hitter.
I started thinking about just how bad the weakest link on a playoff caliber team can be. Can the Red Sox get to the playoffs with Todd Walker playing second base everyday? While it would be impossible to answer this, I decided to take a look at the respective weakest links from the Red Sox’ playoff competition, Seattle, Oakland, and the New York Yankees.
For Oakland, there were a number of candidates. As everyone knows, it’s the pitching that makes this team run but three candidates stick out offensively. Mark Ellis has been bad but he plays a great second-base. Scott Hatteberg has been no bargain but Billy Beane loves Scott Hatteberg. So does Michael Lewis. So does Peter Gammons. So I suppose we love him too. That leaves Terrence Long:
Season: .251 / .299 / .411
July: .259 / .300 / .400
August: .250 / .276 / .518
That’s not very good but he deserves credit for his power surge this month. Walker’s worse.
Seattle is a beautifully balanced team, strong defensively everywhere and consistent offensively. I hate to do it to my man because I would give anything to have him back at this point in time but sorry Rey, you are Seattle’s worst regular at the moment. Here are Dirty’s numbers:
Season: .242 / .276 / .263
July: .149 / .180 / .149 (in limited action)
August: .350 / .375 / .350
For most of this season, Sanchez has been awful at the plate. Still, for his recent revival and his tremendous glove, I am forced to give him the nod as well over Walker.
With everybody healthy, the New York Yankees have a very good offense with no holes. As far as I can tell, their worst regular is the guy for whom they traded their best pitching prospect – Aaron Boone. His numbers:
Season: .260 / .321 / .442
July: .295 / .368 / .438
August: .169 / .194 / .254
In addition to his superior offensive numbers, Boone also plays a strong third base. There is no comparison here.
I don’t know what this all means but I have been thinking a lot about Todd Walker and it makes me miserable. I needed to make sure there was good reason for my misery. Well, there is. The Red Sox have the worst regular in the Seattle – Oakland – NYY – Boston four-way race.