David Pinto had this to write over at his fantastic blog this morning.
“As I look at the standings this morning, the Yankees have the best record in baseball. Now given the team Cashman and Co. have assembled, this shouldn’t be a surprise. But consider this:
-Derek Jeter hasn’t hit this season.
-Bernie Williams hasn’t hit this season.
-Sheffield hasn’t hit for power this season.
-Mike Mussina has been awful.
-Contreras has been awful.
-Giambi’s been on the DL.
-They have gotten nothing from second base.
Despite all that, they are tied with the Red Sox for the league lead in runs scored with 289. I find that a bit scary. Three of their best hitters in slumps, and they are at the top of the league in runs scored. And it looks like Jeter and Sheffield are starting to hit again. Giambi comes off the DL on Sunday. Matsui is playing more like he used to in Japan. A-Rod is A-Rod. Posada just keeps getting on base. If they can score like this with their offense not hitting on all cyliners, what are they going to be like when everything is in place? What if Mussina regains his form? It’s doubtful that even the return of Nomar and Nixon will be enough to overcome this juggernaught.”
To which I responded in his comments section…
“As I look at the standings this morning, the Red Sox are just 2 games behnd the Yankees. Now given the team Theo and Co. have assembled, this shouldn’t be a surprise. But consider this:
- Nomar hasn’t played an inning this season
- Kevin Millar hasn’t hit this season
- David Ortiz hasn’t gotten on base this season
- Derek Lowe has been beyond awful
- Kim and Arroyo have been awful
- Nixon’s on the DL
- They have gotten nothing from RF
Despite all that, they are tied with the Yankees for the league lead in runs scored with 289. I find that a bit scary. Two of their four best hitters having not played even a single inning and they are at the top of the league in runs scored. And it looks like Nomar and Nixon are getting healthier. Nomar comes off the DL and will play Tuesday. Damon is playing more like he used to in Kansas City. Manny is Manny. Varitek just keeps getting on base. If they can score like this with their offense not hitting on all cyliners, what are they going to be like when everything is in place? What if Lowe regains his form? It’s doubtful that even the return of Giambi will be enough to overcome this juggernaught.”
My contention was not that the Red Sox are clearly better, but rather that trying to conclusively decide which team is better at this point is crazy. Both teams have persevered and performed quite nicely in the face of some adversity. Last night, the Yankees beat the Orioles 6-5, scoring their 6 runs on just 3 hits. Meanwhile, Pedro was hit hard as Vlad had a career night,leading the Halos to a 10-7 win over the Sox.
I thought that pointing out the Yankees are “the best of the best” this particular morning was a case of shortsightedness on Pinto’s part. The Yankees have proven themselves to be the best at this point every bit as much as the Red Sox had proven themselves to be the best on April 25th.
In other words, they’ve proven squat.