I’m going to take a slightly different bent on this preview, so bear with me. Let me get the basics out of the way.
St. Louis Cardinals
2005: 100-62 1st in the NL Central, defeated the San Diego Padres (3-0) in the NLDS, lost to the Houston Astros (4-2) in the NLCS
Projected Lineup
SS David Eckstein
2B Junior Spivey
3B Scott Rolen
1B Albert Pujols
CF Jim Edmonds
RF Juan Encarnacion
LF Larry Bigbie
C Yadier Molina
Projected Rotation
Cris Carpenter
Mark Mulder
Jeff Suppan
Jason Marquis
Sidney Ponson
Projected Closer
Jason Isringhausen
Chicago White Sox
2005: 99-63 1st in the AL Central, defeated the Boston Red Sox (3-0) in the ALDS, defeated the Los Angeles Angels (of Anaheim) (4-1) in the ALCS, defeated the Houston Astros (4-0) in the World Series
Projected Lineup
CF Scott Podsednik
2B Tadahito Iguchi
DH Jim Thome
1B Paul Konerko
RF Jermaine Dye
C A.J. Pierzynski
3B Joe Crede
SS Juan Uribe
CF Brian Anderson
Projected Rotation
Mark Buehrle
Freddy Garcia
Jose Contreras
Jon Garland
Javier Vazquez
Projected Closer
Bobby Jenks
The only thing that can stop the Cardinals from winning the NL Central and being the favorite to win the NL is Father Time. He’s approaching, and approaching fast, but I think he’s probably a year off.
That’s what I said last season about the St. Louis Cardinals, and I think that was about as accurate as one can get in a prognostication. The Cardinals cruised to their second straight 100+ win season, and lost a competitive NLCS to an Astros team that was simply on fire.
Couple that with a likely improved staff (upon the return of the injured Buehrle) and I think that’s a recipe for a couple game improvement. 85 wins probably won’t be enough to win the division, especially with every other team in the AL Central arguably improved, but this team is good enough to take the Central should the Twins slip.
On the other hand, they’re managed by Ozzie Guillen. Maybe I should reverse that 85 and 77.
Unfortunately, I wasn’t as accurate on my analysis of the White Sox. They outperformed my prediction by a full 14 wins, and Ozzie Guillen was pretty much the consensus manager of the millenium, as he guided the Pale Hose to their first World Series victory since well before the elderly could recline in their Craftmatic adjustable beds (honestly – I’ve always just wanted to make a Craftmatic reference). The White Sox pitching staff was stellar and had one of the most dominating post-season performances in history.
So here we have two teams, the two teams with the best records in their leagues, with GMs of differing reputations. Walt Jocketty is, for the most part, considered to be a solid GM. Not the most inventive guy, but good enough to use the resources he has to put together teams that are consitently good (they’ve made the playoffs in 5 out of the last 6 seasons). Ken Williams was widely ridiculed (and quite often by me), considered to be a guy who didn’t get it, a guy who has a big market team that simply couldn’t get over the hump. When the going got rough, he got a new manager. Since he took over in 2001, the team had never finished with less than 81 wins, but never more than 86.
Then 2005 happened.
Everything came together for the White Sox. The small ball offense did enough to stay in games, while the pitching staff just shut down the opposition. When I say shut down the opposition, I mean it in about as dominating way as one can. The team ERA+ was 123. Just absolute domination.
Likewise, the St. Louis Cardinals dominated their opposition. The team ERA+ … also 123, just like the Pale Hose. The offense was less exciting than usual, as Scott Rolen spent most of the season on the sidelines, and only the great Albert Pujols had a full, healthy, stellar season. The entire starting outfield (Edmonds, Walker, Sanders) hit well–but none played an entire season. The Cardinals got by on their dominant pitching and it carried them to the NLCS where they ran into a team with more dominant pitching.
So, 2005. Two teams, two dominant staffs, the clear cream of their leagues. What would 2006 hold for them? What would Jocketty and Williams do to help get their teams over the hump?
Oddly enough, it would be Ken Williams who would do the most. Walt Jocketty stood back. He let Matt Morris leave–not a huge loss given Morris’ recent performance, but he replaced him with Sidney Ponson and Anthony Reyes. Reyes will be good, and good soon, but there’s not a whole lot of room for error there, given the variability in pitching from year to year and the injury histories of Mark Mulder and Cris Carpenter. Gone from the dominant pen are Al Reyes, Ray King, and Julian Tavarez. In their stead? Braden Looper, Ricardo Rincon, and Josh Hancock. It’s tough to project bullpens, and the Cardinals did get younger, but I think it’s a safe bet the bullpen will be less successful in 2006.
Jocketty lost Walker to retirement, and Sanders to KC. He replaced them with Larry Bigbie and Juan Encarnacion. Both are ok players. Neither has been, to this point in their careers, good enough to carry a corner outfield spot. Junior Spivey replaces Mark Grudzielanek at 2B. Again, the Cards got younger, but they didn’t get better. Overall, these three offensive additions probably net the Cards a net -50 runs. The only saving grace is the return of a healthy Scott Rolen, who at age 31, should still have something left to compete with David Wright as the best 3B in the NL. This is a team that, at best, is probably a treaded water (and likely lost 25-50 runs offensively and defensively). In the newly hyper-competitive NL Central, that might not be enough to keep the Cards on top. Or certainly not on top for very long.
Ken Williams could have sat back and reaped the rewards of a World Series victory. He could have sat there, knowing that his team probably wasn’t as good as their record said, and let 2006 take its course, secure in his position as the man who brought a title to Chicago. He didn’t. He traded away fan favorite Aaron Rowand, bringing in Jim Thome to take bats at DH. He traded for Javier Vazquez to replace the weak link in the pitching staff (Orlando Hernandez) and make a formidable pitching staff more formidable.
Not many GMs would trade away the starting CF and a starting pitcher from a World Series winning club. But Williams did what needed to be done to make his team better and take advantage of some of the new revenue headed to the Sox. With Thome, the offense will be better and will not need to rely on nearly as much small ball to win. With Vazquez, the White Sox still have the best pitching in the league, and now have Brandon McCarthy ready to step in when needed, should someone get hurt or fall apart. The White Sox still won’t score 1000 runs, but they’ll score 800.
You have to figure on some regression on the part of both pitching staffs. If the Cards staff regresses much at all, the offense won’t be there to pick up the slack. Similarly, if the Sox staff regresses, the offense won’t be there to carry it, but it will be enough to keep them above water (whereas last season, they would have drowned). Two teams, seemingly moving in opposite directions, but are in similar situations in recent history. Fittingly, they’ll have similar records:
St. Louis Cardinals
Projection: 92-70
Chicago White Sox
Projection: 92-70