
The Red Sox stand in first place in the AL East, with the best record in baseball and a 10 game lead. Obviously, things have gone a bit better than expected for this team in the first half of the season.
So, how have the individual contributors fared? Let’s take a look:
Hideki Okajima - A+
Going into this season, the biggest question mark was the team’s bullpen, a mix of fading veterans and rag-tag free-agents. Little did we know, the most effective guy out of the pen wouldn’t be Jonathan Papelbon, Brendan Donnelly, or any of the guys mentioned as “closer candidates” early in the year. All-Star Hideki Okajima leads the team in appearances, relief innings, and has a mind-blowing 0.83 ERA (539 ERA+), 0.831 WHIP. Certainly deserving of that final vote, and quite possibly the first-half MVP of this team.
Josh Beckett - A
When he’s able to throw his curveball, he is among the game’s most dominant pitchers. His K/BB ratio has nearly doubled in a year, going from 2.14 last year to 4.38 in 2007. Be watching tonight…
Dustin Pedroia - A
Not much was expected from the rookie 2B after his anemic debut in 2006, coupled with his abysmal start to this year. The miniscule middle-infielder followed up an awful April (.544 OPS) with a torrid May (1.072 OPS), and hasn’t looked back. Has also played stellar 2B defense, which is perhaps more surprising than his gaudy offensive numbers.
Mike Lowell - A-
He had the odd early-season glove issues, but those seem to be a thing of the past (and luckily didn’t cost the team many games). I keep expecting this guy to fall apart, but it just has not happened. Arguably the best hitter and most valuable player on the team thus far. It’s hard not to like Mike.
Jonathan Papelbon - A-
He’s given up a couple of high-profile HRs this year, already matching the 2006 total of 3, and his ERA has gone from unbelievable to plain-old phenominal. Even considering that, he’s still among the game’s elite relief arms, and probably the one guy I’d pick in the entire league if I needed 1 out. K rate has jumped from 9.88 to 12.67 this year.
Kevin Youkilis - A-
The facial muff alone gets him at least a B. Youk has quietly been one of the most productive hitters on the team. Many nay-sayers believe his power spike was just an early hot streak, but keep in mind, he’s 28 - prime career year terriroty.
David Ortiz - B+
You really can’t win in this town. After a 3 year streak in which he was the most feared hitter in baseball, personifying the word “clutch”, causing even the likes of Bill James to backtrack on what was recently considered contemporary baseball wisdom, David Ortiz has seen his power slightly decrease (IsoP has gone from .349 to .242). This has caused a slight panic in this town, one of those ridiculous East Coast things that just makes me chuckle. His OPS is .990.
Jason Varitek - B+
If any of you have a job which requires you to wear an arm-band with Japanese to English translations printed on it, my advice to you is to request a raise. Tek has increased his offensive production from his off year in 2006, and has managed to keep Julian Tavarez from killing people.
Daisuke Matsuzaka - B
He’s been wildly inconsistent, spinning a gem one night and getting lit up the next. However, his stuff cannot be denied, as many hitters have walked away from Dice-K encounters muttering, amazed and annoyed with his vast arsenal. Despite the inconsistency, overall, he’s been pretty much as advertized: a durable horse with an electric array of pitches, as he sits among the league leaders in strikeouts and innings pitched.
The Rest of The Bullpen - B
I’m going to group together the following guys here: Brendan Donnelly, Kyle Snyder, Javier Lopez, Joel Pineiro, Mike Timlin, and Manny Delcarmen. For my entire life, I’ve always been a “B Student” (i.e. I’m lazy and uninspired, but I try not to f*ck up too often). The back-end of the bullpen, for the most part, has been just that. Sure, there is some skewness here (Delcarmen and Snyder have been excellent, while Timlin and Pineiro have been frustrating), but over 143.3 innings pitched, these 6 guys have combined for an ERA of 3.54. Nice work, but would I really want any one of them on the mound with the game on the line and inherited runners on base?
Manny Ramirez - B-
Like Ortiz, Manny has encountered a decrease in power in 2007, as his IsoP has decreased from .298 to .181. His contact rate and walk rates remain the same, and thus he has still been a very productive hitter, although his 6.23 Runs Created Per 27 Outs is the worst of his 14 year career. When taking into consideration the fact that he turned 35 in May, this becomes a concern.
Tim Wakefield - B-
After all these years, still one of the most underappreciated players on the team. He’s been the 3rd best starter, and continues to provide steady innings, with an ERA+ of 102. He’s only slightly above average (as always), but that’s more than we can say about most starting pitchers in the American League.
Coco Crisp - B-
This grade is driven primarily by his excellent work in CF as well as the basepaths this season. Coco has quite possibly been the best fielding CF in the league in 2007, and his bat has begun to come around, as well (hitting .321 in June and July).
Curt Schilling - C+
His recent rough patch and injury means it is somewhat likely that this will be his last season Curt pitches in Boston. While he was healthy, our blogging colleague was effective this season, including a near no-hitter in Oakland. He threw more quality innings than predicted by many, given his age and stature. I’m not going to write his eulogy yet, since there’s always the chance he returns healthy and wins another 6-8 games in the second half. As we’ve seen, if anything, Curt is driven.
Julian Tavarez - C
Probably shouldn’t even receive a C, but I might be biased. A likeable character, at least there won’t be any complaints about his focus and desire. Sporting a 4.97 ERA in a role that is probably ill-suited for him, but acting as a pseudo-leader and spokesman in the clubhouse. I’d probably rather see one of our minor league guys in the rotation, but Julian has exceeded my modest expectations of him.
J.D. Drew - C
I’m not going to spend much time on him, because frankly, I’m tired of discussing him. I’m naturally a “glass half full” person (in regards to baseball, anyway), and my natural reaction is to shrug off his mediocre first-half - which puts me in the vast minority of Boston fandom. The only exhibit I’ll offer is his recent play: over June and July, J.D. is hitting .307 with an OBP over .400.
The Bench - D-
OK, now we get into the suck. The one guy saving this unit from an F-minus is Alex Cora, who has hit .278/.326/.444 (although the 2B “controversy” is now deader than Anna Nicole Smith). Aside from Alex, the trio of Erik Hinske, Wily Mo Pena, and Doug Mirabelli have combined to hit .199 with 103 Ks in 282 at-bats. Just to put this in perspective, if the three-headed monster were to have a full season of 600 at-bats, they would strike out 219 times.
Julio Lugo - F+
The + is for baserunning. I tried very hard to justify not giving him an F. He seems to try very hard, he’s stolen a bunch of bases, and he’s been sort of unlucky with BABIP…but still. If Julio’s secong half is anything like his first, he would qualify as the worst starting SS in Red Sox history, as well as one of the worst free-agent signings in baseball history. He did have 3 hits in his last game, so maybe his confidence spiked a little going into the break? One can only hope.