I’ve had a few days to digest a little.
There is a story you heard everywhere this week, at least as far as baseball goes. In August, 2006 when the rest of the season was falling apart for the Red Sox, one of their top prospects, Jon Lester, was scratched from a start with a sore back. After a week of testing (orginially, the back soreness was thought to be a by-product of a car crash), it was announced that Lester had a treatable form of lymphoma.
Less than a year later, he toed the rubber at Jacobs Field, and won. Fourteen months after his diagnosis, he got the win in the clinching game of the 2007 World Series. Twenty-two months after he was told he had cancer, Lester threw a no hitter against the Kansas City Royals, being the 18th Red Sox pitcher to throw a no hitter, and joining Nolan Ryan as only the second guy to no hit the Royals in their history.
This is all stuff you can read anywhere, even if I don’t fawn over how inspirational it was for Lester to throw a no-hitter. Some people can draw inspiration from things like that, but I’m not one of them…it’s just not how I’m wired.
No, what I got out of the no hitter is that there are two Jon Lesters, and the one we’ll all hear about it probably the one that he’s sick and tired of being.
The Jon Lester we will hear about is how he beat cancer, and then had a charmed year from July 07 to now. Lester isn’t a pitcher anymore, he’s a Cancer Survivor who happens to pitch. When he was interviewed after the game on Monday, he was asked about the cancer quite a bit by the press, and by Heidi Watney on the field. Varitek and Francona, who understandably showed a great amount of emotion, were asked about how special Lester was in defeating cancer. Lester is a Cancer Survivor, above all else.
The other Jon Lester was visably uncomfortable talking about his cancer after throwing a no hitter, like he was sick of talking about it. This Jon Lester is a former top prospect and potential rotation mainstay with the defending World Champions. This Lester throw his cutter too much, even if it’s flat, and doesn’t have a consistant breaking pitch. This Lester was almost traded to the White Sox in the 2003 off season merry-go-round that would have landed Alex Rodriguez and Magglio Ordonez in Boston.
This Lester pitched the game of his life against the Royals.
I write this at the risk of sounding insensitive, and that’s not my intent. I think it is tremendous that he beat cancer, and I would think that about anyone who had a cancer scare. Though the fatality rate of his type of lymphoma is fairly low, cancer isn’t something I would wish on anyone, and the fact that he was pitching less than a year after diagnosis is remarkable.
But beating cancer has created a narrative that has glossed over who Jon Lester is. After Monday, Varitek got credit for catching his fourth no-hitter. Lester got credit for beating cancer.
Going forward, it’s important to realize that Jon Lester shouldn’t be pigeon-holed as a Cancer Survivor, because his accomplishments on the field become a subset of that…and he seems tired of talking about it.