When I heard of the passing of young Angels rookie pitcher Nick Adenhart a few weeks ago, I couldn’t help but think about other major leaguers who died while in the midst of their career. If you’re at all familiar with pre-WWII baseball, you know that this type of thing happened a lot more often back then (tuberculosis was a real bitch). Would Adenhart make a 25-man roster of ballplayers who passed away while in the middle of their playing careers? Let’s take a look:
STARTING LINEUP:
C: Thurman Munson – Munson might have been a Hall of Famer were it not for the 1979 plane crash that took his life. With a career OPS+ of 116 in his ten plus seasons with the Yankees, an argument can be made that he should be in. He was a perfect representative for Yankee Universe: an big obnoxious guy with a mustache.
1B: Harry Agganis – There is a life-sized statue of this guy not 200 feet from where I currently sit. A local guy through and through, Harry was born in Lynn and attended Boston University, where he was a legendary football quarterback. He was drafted by the Cleveland Browns to replace Hall of Fame QB Otto Graham, but the Browns were outbid by Tom Yawkey. Agganis was hitting .313/.383/.458 when he died of a pulmonary embolism at age 26.
2B: Ken Hubbs – At age 20, Ken was maybe one of the worst Rookie of the Year winners in the history of the award (a .646 OPS with mediocre defense apparently was enough). Hubbs had a fear of flying, which he tried to overcome by actually becoming a pilot. That took some guts, regardless of the result. I have a fear of scorpions, and I couldn’t imagine trying to become a scorpion rancher.
3B: Tony Boeckel – Third base is sort of weak in this category. Boeckel was an average third baseman for the Boston Braves (basically the Joe Crede of his day) who died in a car accident in 1924. Since it was 1924, you know the car had to look something like the flying Model-T in The Absent Minded Professor. They did look like fun, but apparently were not entirely safe.
SS: Ray Chapman – As you may or may not know, Chapman was the only guy ever to be killed by a HBP. The pitcher was hard-throwing Carl Mays of the Yankees. Some believe this incident is an impenetrable barrier standing between Mays and Cooperstown.
LF: Ed Delahanty – Ed was a Hall of Famer and maybe the best hitter on this entire team (era adjusted). He was the Manny Ramirez of 19th century baseball, in that he was a feared hitter and something of an enigma wrapped in a riddle wrapped in some sort of crazy gift wrapping. Ed died after jumping (falling?) into Niagara Falls.
CF: Chick Stahl – The Red Sox player-manager took his own life by chugging some carbolic acid during spring training in Indiana. I suppose if I had to endure spring training in Indiana, I might bat around the idea of offing myself in the most painful way possible.
RF: Roberto Clemente – If you are ever looking some evidence for the whole “There Is No God” argument, just reference the story of a superstar athlete who dies in a plane crash on his way to do charity work in a third-world country.
DH: Lyman Bostock – Lyman was shot and killed in Gary, Indiana (see my Chick Stahl comment above). Bostock’s killer served all of 21 months in prison. I think the South Carolina DA was seeking a longer sentence for Michael Phelps in his pot possession case.
Bench:
OF: Len Koenecke – A year after hitting .320/.411/.509 for the Brooklyn Dodgers, Koenecke was bludgeoned to death with a fire extinguisher by a flight attendant, reportedly after flipping out mid-flight.
CIF: Dan McGann – A dead-ball era 1B who had a lengthy career with over 400 stolen bases and an OPS+ of 117, McGann shot himself in a Lousisville hotel.
IF: Elmer Gedeon
C: Harry O’Neill
Gedeon and O’Neill hold the honor of being the only two MLB players killed in World War II.
ROTATION:
1) Addie Joss – A dominant turn-of-the-century Hall of Fame pitcher. Joss only pitched 8+ seasons in his career before dying of meningitis at age 30. The Hall of Fame broke their “10 year rule” and in 1978 allowed Joss in as a rare exception.
2) Urban Shocker – Urban is one of the more underrated pitchers in baseball history. With a career 124 ERA+ in nearly 3,000 innings, there is a salient Hall of Fame argument to be made for the guy with perhaps the coolest name in baseball history. Were it not for pneumonia, the argument would be much easier to make.
3) Darryl Kile – As someone who is close to the same age and the same size as Kile was when his heart stopped, I wish I knew the cause of his death. Whatever it was, I’d like to avoid it.
4) Don Wilson – Wilson died of carbon monoxide poisoning in 1975 (car running in the garage). At the age of 29, he had amassed 104 wins and a 3.15 ERA.
5) Nick Adenhart – Nick cracks the rotation based almost entirely on his potential. I believe he was rushed to the major leagues (and even to the hitter-friendly AAA Pacific Coast League), but if cultivated properly, Nick might have been an outstanding starting pitcher. In 2006 he combined for a 15-4 season with a 2.56 ERA in the low minors, and in 2007 he was 10-8 with a 3.65 ERA in AA.
BULLPEN
Closer: Steve Olin – Steve was a shut-down closer for the Cleveland Indians before dying in a boating accident at the age of 27.
Set-up: Donnie Moore – In 1985, Donnie pitched 103 innings out of the bullpen while only yielding a 1.92 ERA. A year later, it began to fall apart.
Set-up: Danny Frisella – Frisella was killed in a dube buggy accident in 1977. HE was a decent set-up man for a number of years (career 3.32 ERA).
Middle: Tim Crews – A solid releiver who was on the boat with Olin.
Middle: Cory Lidle – My one enduring memory of the ill-fated pilot was his role in that wild Tampa Bay-Boston game where just about everyone was ejected and/or suspended and Pedro pitched a near-perfect game. Lidle was the guy who came in, tried to hit Brian Daubach twice, missed both times, and was promptly ejected.
Long: Tiny Bonham – A career 3.06 ERA in over 1,500 innings before dying of appendicitis.
Long: Bob Moose – The elevated pitcher’s mound in 1969 did not affect Bob Moose, as he went 14-3 with a 2.91 ERA and an impressive 8.7 K/9 as a swingman. Moose died in a car wreck on his 29th birthday.