
HoF'er Jimmy Collins, considered by many to be the greatest pre-WWII third baseman.
After months of dismal winter highlighted by earthquakes, flooding, and skyrocketing unemployment rates, a pleasant distraction in the form of the 2010 baseball season has arrived. Technically, this team preview is a day late, but hopefully not a dollar short.
Arrivals: John Lackey (SP), Mike Cameron (CF), Adrian Beltre (3B), Marco Scutaro (SS), Scott Schoeneweis (RP), Scott Atchison (RP), Bill Hall (IF), Jeremy Hermida (OF)
Departures: Jason Bay (LF), Billy Wagner (RP), Takashi Saito (RP), Casey Kotchman (1B), Ales Gonzalez (SS)
You know by now that the Red Sox have undergone a significant facelift over the winter, both in terms of roster makeup and strategy. The large number of names on that “arrivals” list sort of highlights the massive rebalancing effort undertaken by the front office in the past few months. The one significant personnel loss is, of course, power-hitting outfielder Jason Bay. In his absence, the Red Sox will try a different approach in 2010: an increased focus on run prevention.
Projected 2010 Starting Lineup:
|
Name |
Offense |
Fielding |
| LF |
Jacoby Ellsbury |
7.0 |
8.5 |
| 2B |
Dustin Pedroia |
8.5 |
9.0 |
| C |
Victor Martinez |
8.5 |
|
| 1B |
Kevin Youkilis |
9.0 |
9.5 |
| DH |
David Ortiz |
7.5 |
|
| RF |
J.D. Drew |
8.5 |
8.0 |
| 3B |
Adrian Beltre |
6.5 |
10.0 |
| CF |
Mike Cameron |
7.5 |
9.0 |
| SS |
Marco Scutaro |
7.0 |
7.0 |
Projected 2010 Bench:
|
Name |
Offense |
Fielding |
| C |
Jason Varitek |
4.5 |
|
| IF |
Bill Hall |
4.0 |
7.5 |
| OF |
Jeremy Hermida |
7.5 |
4.5 |
| CIF |
Mike Lowell |
8.5 |
3.0 |
As you can see by glancing at those fielding ratings juxtaposed with the hitting ratings, this Red Sox team in unlike any we have seen in recent memory. While the gloves are obviously a strong point in comparison to the bats, the offense should be able to hold their own. They won’t outscore the Yankees over the course of the year, but a top 5 finish in AL runs in likely. The biggest question marks are with Adrian Beltre’s bat, and the team’s exposure to left-handed pitching (particularly Ortiz, Drew, and Ellsbury).
There might be a way to hedge the latter problem. I made this post over the winter illustrating how Boston could actually keep Mike Lowell on the roster and use him to their advantage. Now that the deal with the Texas Rangers has fallen through, it looks like the Sox might actually retain the veteran corner infielder’s services this season. It might not be what Lowell wants (understandably, he’d prefer to go to a team where he would be a primary starter), but it might be the best scenario for the Red Sox, given David Ortiz’ deteriorating abilities against left-handed pitchers.
I am very bearish on Bill Hall, however, the Sox do have Jed Lowrie on the DL. Lowrie will get a chance to prove himself in AAA, and if he heats up in Pawtucket while Hall struggles up here, a change will be made.
Projected 2010 Rotation:
|
Name |
Pitching |
| SP1 |
Josh Beckett |
8.0 |
| SP2 |
Jon Lester |
9.0 |
| SP3 |
John Lackey |
8.5 |
| SP4 |
Tim Wakefield |
5.5 |
| SP5 |
Clay Buchholz |
7.5 |
The front three is as strong as any other in the major leagues. The question marks come after John Lackey’s turn in the rotation. Tim Wakefield is the king of the league average 100 ERA+ performance, which would normally be palatable from a 4th or 5th starter. However, his age and health raise concerns, as a 40+ ballplayer’s abilities could erode at any time. Timmy could see a sharp decline in performance, and when it happens, his effectiveness is probably gone for good. To his credit, he did look fine in the spring. Clay Buchholz’ talent is not in question, but his ability to successfully challenge MLB hitters on a consistent basis has yet to be proved.
For now, I’ll keep Daisuke Matsuzaka out of the equation. He’s going to make a few rehab starts in the minors before making his 2010 MLB debut, which means a few weeks on the shelf, at minimum. If he does return and proves to be ineffective, his 2010 campaign will go a lot like 2009: a long, frustrating shell game between the DL and various minor league affiliates.
Projected 2010 Bullpen:
|
Name |
Pitching |
| MR |
Scott Schoeneweis |
5.5 |
| MR |
Manny Delcarmen |
6.5 |
| MR |
Scott Atchison |
6.5 |
| MR |
Hideki Okajima |
8.0 |
| MR |
Ramon Ramirez |
8.0 |
| MR |
Daniel Bard |
9.0 |
| CL |
Jonathan Papelbon |
9.5 |
The Sox bullpen takes a step after Billy Wagner and Takashi Saito, two reliable set-up arms, leave as free-agents. They are replaced by Scott Atchison, a wild card who had moderate success in Japan these past two years, and Scott Schoenewies, a pitcher who might have some marginal use in situational “LOOGY” roles. I’m assuming that Atchison performs at the level of an average AL middle reliever, since we really don’t have too much to go on. While the back end of the bullpen is fairly secure with the combination of Papelbon, Bard, and Ramirez, the early bullpen could prove to be a weakness if a starter can’t go beyond 5 or so innings.
For a team playing in one of the more notorious hitting environments in the game, shifting from an offensive focus to a pitching/defense focus could prove to be a difficult transition. On paper, the team does not have the raw talent to match New York, but they aren’t far off. The Sox will need to stay healthy and avoid any significant regression in order to win baseball’s strongest division, the American League East. naturally, the Sox come up with the second highest team score out of all the squads I previewed.
Team Score: 7.56
As always, the Red Sox will field a competitive team, and at the very least, they will provide us with some long-awaited entertainment for the next 6 months.
Next: league predictions (standings, awards, World Series winners)